Over the past several weeks, I’ve attended about ten evenings of the protests in Rochester following the death of Daniel Prude at the hands of Rochester police, and the ensuing 6-month cover-up. Suddenly, Rochester had all the potential to become Ferguson or Kenosha – nightly violence, people hurt or killed, burning and looting included. I want to relate, from my observations, why this has not occurred in Rochester.
To be sure, the potential was there!
The first night, after the video went viral, about 200 protesters who gathered in front of the Public Safety Building were vocal but law-abiding. Without warning, the police moved on them with tear gas and pepper-ball guns, despite the fact that they were making no move to do anything other than protest.
The second night, as the protestors – now about 1500 – marched toward the Public Safety Building, the Rochester Police Department (RPD) trapped them on the Court St. bridge. Again, they had stopped moving, but the police, with no warning at all, opened up again with tear gas and a barrage of pepper balls.
By the third night, the group that became known as Elders and Allies had been formed, initiated by Shirley and James Thompson and Kit Miller, later combined with an initiative by Rev. Myra Brown. As part of this group, my wife Sue and I marched with the protestors, partly to discourage the police from attacking.
The protestors were incensed after undergoing the unprovoked assaults the prior nights. And it was known that some outsiders had joined their ranks. The chants were stronger, more heated. The front lines of protestors were equipped with homemade shields, football helmets, padded clothing, whatever they could use to protect themselves. All defensive wear; no offensive weapons of any kind in sight. Teams of medics were ready with eye wash and medical supplies to treat those wounded. The group came up to the barricades on Plymouth and halted. Then someone tossed a commercial-grade firework at the police. Several more were thrown. The police threw some back to the protestors before they exploded. Some bottles and rocks were thrown. But realizing that they had gotten poor press for their aggression the first two nights, the police waited eight minutes, as they reported later; then they opened up again, raining pepper balls, tear gas, and flashbangs, hitting reporters as well as Elders and Allies who had hoped to protect the protestors.
In response to questioning by City Council two weeks later, RPD reported that 6100 rounds of pepper balls had been launched in those three nights. To be sure, there were salty, accusatory chants lobbed across the lines. This verbal assault had to be painful for the officers to absorb. Still, all we witnessed was well within the rights of protest, and not a valid excuse for such a dangerous, punishing reaction from people pledged to serve and protect.
So, you might be asking, where are those signs of hope I promised?
On the fourth night, about 100 of us Elders and Allies stood right at the barricades in front of the Public Safety Building. Mayor Warren, with persuasion from Rev. Myra Brown, had finally ordered the police to stand down. The protests were still loud, very passionate, and yet disciplined.
And for the most part, RPD let them be.
Since that night, the protests have retained passion and determination, and have remained peaceful. Based on reports from trusted observers, the rock-tossing and bottle-throwing on the first couple of nights was done mostly by young, white activists, likely anarchists, who seem to have moved on. I do know from several reports that when something was thrown at police, organizers and/or elders around that person immediately admonished them. City Hall was decorated with slogans and posters, but again, the organizers disciplined the others not to actually destroy anything. They took quick action when a couple of rogue demonstrators (if there can be rogue police, there can be rogue demonstrators) attempted to break through a door there.
In the meantime, the “protests” have morphed into various forms:
- An evening reception/feeding/support for Daniel Prude’s family, some of whom traveled from Chicago.
- Gatherings in front of City Hall marked by music and dancing.
- Providing food and shelter for anyone who needed it.
- A very touching memorial service at MLK Park to honor all those killed by violence in Rochester over the years.
- A birthday celebration for Daniel on what would have been his 42nd birthday, complete with a huge sheet cake for his family and decorated cupcakes for the crowd.
- Educational and inspirational presentations about history and racial justice and love.
More hope: I cannot say enough about the organizers of these events. I had already come to know many of them in the work I’ve been doing, but these days brought out the very best in their leadership, their dedication, their spirituality, their generosity. Especially, I want to give appreciation for Ashley Gantt and Iman Abid of Free The People ROC. I also learned so much in listening to Adrian Elim, Danielle Ponder, Stanley Martin, and Anthony Hall among many others.
More hope: The protests continue. The police seem to have learned that their aggressive, militaristic tactics are unnecessary. Or at least, they’ve cut back. I’d like to think some of the chants had penetrated. I was especially struck by this one, as protestors stood in front of the Public Safety Building: “Why are you in riot gear? We don’t see no riot here!” Or maybe the melodic, mantra-like chant, “Which side are you on, my people, which side are you on?” Whether the learning will be sustained remains to be seen. The appointment of this particular Interim Police Chief, Cynthia Herriott-Sullivan, is another sign of hope according to several people whose knowledge and opinions I trust.
More hope: While the protests go on, the work of shaping a fully-reimagined police/public safety cohort is just getting started. One key leader in this work is Rev. Lewis Stewart, President of United Christian Leadership Ministry (UCLM), an organization I’ve connected with for the past three years. He was cited by many of the organizers as one who can bring the real work forward, since he has a unique ability to bridge divides. He is highly respected by the main organizers, and also highly regarded by the City and County officials who will be key in implementing any actual changes. And UCLM has assembled a powerful cadre of about three dozen people, including some current and past law enforcement leaders, who are right now shaping specific proposals.
More hope: One of the most positive statements giving rise to my hope came in a planning meeting I attended in which one of the main protest organizers, Ashley Gantt of Free the People ROC, said to Rev. Stewart, “We run. We burn bridges. That’s what we do. But we count on you being behind us, with your connections, ready to get down to the table and make the changes!” This kind of synergistic vision is vital! And as I’ve seen with Ashley, Iman and others in the past, they’ll eventually be at the table too! We need both the churn and the table work.
One final bit of hope, on a very personal note: My wife Sue and I were at the birthday event. I had heard Joe Prude, Daniel’s older brother, in a couple of interviews express a gnawing sense of guilt: “I called the police to get help for my brother, and he wound up dead!” I found it heartbreaking that he was saddling himself with that undeserved burden. So at the birthday party, I met him. He showed an immediate warmth and appreciation for our being there, and gave me a brotherly hug (masks on). I said to him, “I’ve heard you a few times, Joe, talking about the guilt that you feel for Daniel’s death. Please don’t do that to yourself! I’m more guilty than you are, because I’m a part of the system that allowed that to happen.” Without hesitation, he was telling me not to do that to myself! HE was comforting ME!! What a kind, gentle, sensitive soul.
And so I choose to live in hope, and continue to give what I can to the work that’s ahead. I urge you to dedicate yourself as well. No Resources listed this time. The internet is loaded with what to do. Find your work!
Replies welcome, below.
12 thoughts on “The Protests – and Signs of Hope”
Frank, we must all move forward together to achieve yours and my hope! Listen and hold each other’s hands.
Thanks, Frank. I am grateful for your overview of this serious and important time in our city. I have been happy to be there as an “ally” and have been impressed with the passion and intelligence of the organizers. I understand that this is all part of a winding and painful process but I am encouraged at the avenues of communication that are being opened up in this latest struggle. I still experience deep pain when I think of these four hundred years of systemic injustice and can only be grateful that I can help in a small way, joining others, young and old, to bring us all closer to common understanding what reparation needs to look like.
Thank you for adding your view, dear sister! Good to march with you.
Thanks, Frank for sharing. I, too, have hope in the leaders and prophets in our community.
Great piece Frank. I will pass it on.
As usual, I know you mean well, but the most serious, glaring contradiction and shortfall relative to your “hopeful” essay is apparent avoidance of the main, major, underlying issue and cause of this whole, ongoing, historical, deep-seated, socioeconomic, sociopolitical, and sociocultural, SYSTEMIC problem and issue — that’s right — individual, institutional and structural racism ( http://minorityreporter.net/the-tripartite-beast-and-illness-of-individual-institutional-and-structural-racism/ ), which it seems (increasingly) — is not only being pervasively, and I believe intentionally downplayed, but actually ignored and/or dismissed altogether. SHAME!!!
Secondly, I wish that I could view the appointment of the new police chief as “hopeful,” but my observation outlined below is very, very alarming:
Cynthia Herriott-Sullivan named interim police chief in Rochester, first woman in that role
Sept 26, 2020 — Updated Sept 27, 2020
Even though we congratulate Ms.Herriott-Sullivan on her appointment — already there’s a “red-flag” so to speak, e.g., during her very first interview (see the link above), after being named, she clearly demonstrated reluctance or hesitance to deal with the CENTRAL, UNDERLYING ISSUE that led to her appointment, that’s right (without any doubt whatsoever) — individual, institutional, and structural racism.
It is interesting (to say the very least) that during the interview, one of the reporters asked the new chief — “what’s [her] plan for building relationships with protesters and the community?” Though the reporter didn’t ask anything about race, Ms. Herriott-Sullivan obviously felt compelled to unsolicitedly engage in reductionist rhetoric concerning the importance of race (actually RACISM) as a vital factor relative to historical and ongoing unrest and upheaval throughout this white-supremacist-based-nation-state (in every direction — North, East, South, and West).
Out of the blue, she proclaimed clumsily: “It’s not always about race, I’ve seen either.” Why didn’t she raise the issue of class, or some other relevant socioeconomic, sociopolitical, sociocultural factor(s) — why race??? This is NOT a rhetorical question. Do we know the answer?
She definitely displayed white-supremacist-based, internalized, personhood-diminishment, if not self-hatred — when she talked about having a “chuckle” with a white man who was following her around in a clothing store (based on suspiciousness, inspired solely by her Black skin). She even went as far as to suggest (indirectly) that there are people who deserve to be followed around in stores, but just not her, e.g., she claimed that, in addition to showing the store detective her badge, and having a “chuckle” — she had wanted to “free [him] up [so that he] could deal with somebody else,” and she didn’t “take that personally” — a-damn-mazing!!! This makes me think about the teachings of the Late, brilliant, marvelously-outstanding psychiatrist, Dr. Frances Cress Welsing: https://www.stitcher.com/podcast/cows/the-cows/e/37616144?autoplay=true — LISTEN!!!
APR 12, 2015
“Dr. Frances Cress Welsing [was] a third generation physician, general and child psychologist, and author of the top selling publication, The Isis Papers: The Keys To The Colors. Dr. Welsing offered her view on the exhibition of black people forgiving Racists. She asserted that this was another aspect of our White Supremacy induced mental illness. She offered this analysis before thirteen-year-old Mo’ne Davis was called a “slut” and publicly forgave her White attacker; before the University of Oklahoma’s Levi Pettit delivered a precision-crafted apology for singing about lynching niggers; before Walter Scott’s black mother declared that she had “forgiveness” for the White Man who murdered her son. We’re also excited to hear Dr. Welsing’s thoughts on the sentencing of Atlanta’s black educators and the pattern of sexual terrorism against black people.”
Thirdly, as outline at the following link, the real bottom line is that, in spite of massive, ongoing protests — not much has changed: http://minorityreporter.net/are-our-leaders-making-significant-change-or-just-posturing-wasting-time-and-resources/
Round-and-round we go. If we’re NOT vigilant and astute — where we end up, as we well know, is right back at the old entrenched, status-quo.
The Struggle Continues, and 2020 IS the Year to Call Everybody Out …
Thanks Howard. I know I can count on you to give the emphasis where it belongs. I hadn’t seen the full interview with the new Chief. Yes, awkward statements at best. Still, for this moment, I’m choosing to cling to some signs of hope, and that includes her appointment. TBD.
Still, for this moment, I’m choosing to cling to signs of REALITY — because I remember what the last big campaign of so-called “hope” produced
( https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/deepdive/obama-legacy-promise-hope-44597110 ) — not much, other than a bunch of super-hyper rhetoric and noise — while the old, old, deeply-entrenched, white-supremacist-based-status-quo raged on, and is STILL raging — period.
This gives me hope too, Frank.
Good. I needed to summarize this for my own sake.